TL;DR — the shortlist test
  • Choose on verifiable proof: named reviews on public platforms, a real founder/team you can look up, published pricing.
  • The agency should audit YOUR site before quoting — a price given without looking is a guess with a signature line.
  • Deliverables in writing, month by month. “SEO activities” is not a deliverable.
  • Walk away from: guaranteed #1 rankings, secret link methods, long lock-ins, reports you can’t understand.

Google’s own documentation makes the starting point plainly: hiring an SEO is a big decision that can improve your site — or damage it. The difference between those outcomes is almost always visible before you sign, if you know what to check. This is the checklist we’d hand a friend who wasn’t going to hire us.

Step 1: Know what you’re buying

Decide your primary job first — local visibility, a technical rescue, content growth, e-commerce revenue (our SEO services tree shows how the specialisms break down). An agency strong in one isn’t automatically strong in another, and “full-service” claims should be tested against the specific job you have.

Step 2: Verify the proof, don’t admire it

  • Reviews on platforms you can open — Google, DesignRush, Clutch — with real names attached. Screenshots on their own site prove nothing.
  • A named, findable team. Search the founder. A real agency has people with public profiles and a history; a logo and a contact form is not a team.
  • Case evidence with a mechanism — what was wrong, what they changed, what moved. Percentage claims without the story are marketing, not evidence.
  • Their own website. An SEO agency whose own site is slow, thin or invisible is showing you its ceiling.

Step 3: Red flags — any one is a reason to pause

  • “Guaranteed #1 rankings” — Google’s docs explicitly warn that no one can guarantee this.
  • Link building they won’t describe. If the method is a secret, the method is the risk — and the penalty lands on your domain, not theirs.
  • Long lock-in contracts before any results window. Confident agencies sell month-to-month; the published market norm is retainers in the $500–$2,500/month range (SE Ranking / Backlinko surveys), not hostage terms.
  • Reports full of impressions and “activities” but no rankings-to-revenue line.
  • They own your assets: content, accounts or data held hostage if you leave.

Step 4: The 10 questions to ask

  1. What would you fix first on my site — and how do you know?
  2. What exactly ships in month one, in writing?
  3. Who does the work — names, not “our team”?
  4. How do you build links? (Listen for digital PR, editorial, partnerships.)
  5. What does your monthly report show, and can I see a sample?
  6. How do you handle AI search — what do you measure there?
  7. What timeline is realistic for my market, and what would make it slower?
  8. What do you need from me each month?
  9. If I cancel, what do I keep? (Right answer: everything.)
  10. Who are two clients I can find independently and verify?

Step 5: Score the finalists

CriterionWeak signStrong sign
ProofScreenshots, unnamed logosPublic reviews, findable founder
Process“Trust us, it’s proprietary”Written sequence, audit first
PricingQuoted without looking at your sitePublished plans or audit-based quote
ReportingVanity metricsRankings, traffic, revenue — plain English
Terms6–12 month lock-inMonth-to-month, you keep everything

Full disclosure: we built SEOWebGo to pass this exact checklist — published pricing, a findable founder with public reviews, month-to-month terms, and a free audit before any quote. Don’t take that sentence at face value either: verify it on the About page, where the reviews link to their sources. Then put us through the same 10 questions as everyone else — the audit is free, and it’s yours to keep either way.